Historical context:
Often considered the “new” antisemitism, hatred of Jews can sometimes be masked behind criticism of Israel, the world’s only Jewish State.
It is important to note that it is not antisemitic to criticize Israeli policies and governments.
However, when Jews are held collectively responsible for actions of the Israeli government, it is a form of antisemitic conflation.
Additionally, when criticism of Zionism, sometimes called anti-Zionism, promotes the idea that Israel does not have a right to exist, it is antisemitic. Zionism is support for the Jewish people’s right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland.
Anti-Zionism emerged with the creation of the State of Israel in 1948 but became more radical after the Six-Day War in 1967. In the Soviet Union, anti-American propaganda used the term “Zionists” to demonise and dehumanise Jews, masking its antisemitism behind this euphemism.
Natan Sharansky writes about Three Ds that are used to identify instances of antisemitism behind criticism of Israel:
- Delegitimisation: Does the criticism question Israel’s right to exist?
- Demonisation: Does the criticism portray Israelis in a dehumanising or demonising manner?
- Double standard: Does the criticism apply standards to Israel that are not applied to other countries?
Historical example: Use of anti-Zionist rhetoric to demonise Jews.
Figure 17: Caricature from the Soviet book Poison of Zionism, published after 1983. Yeshiva University Libraries Digital Collection, https://digital.library.yu.edu/object/digital3877.
This cartoon contains anti-American criticism riddled with antisemitic prejudice. The Star of David and the spider represent Israel, and more broadly the Jews, who are falsely accused of controlling and conspiring with the American government and banks to make money.
Contemporary example: Antisemitic conflation and vandalism at Canada’s National Holocaust Monument.
Figure 20: CBC News June 9, 2025 | “National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa defaced with ‘feed me’ graffiti” – Campbell MacDiarmid
As the conflict intensified in Gaza in 2025 and reports of food shortages began to surface, Canada’s Holocaust monument was defaced in red paint with the words “feed me.” This is an example of antisemitic conflation as it implies that Canadian Jews, or even Holocaust memory, were in some way responsible for the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. By targeting a sacred site for the local Jewish community, this act shifts the political debate into an attack on the identity and history of the Jewish people.